Bills’ Josh Allen & Hailee Steinfeld’s Best Halloween Costumes
Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen and actress Hailee Steinfeld are known for their on-field and on-screen talents, but they also share a knack for show-stopping Halloween costumes. Each year, the couple captures attention with their creative and often nostalgic outfits, giving fans a glimpse into their fun-loving relationship.
From movie tributes to themed parties, Allen and Steinfeld consistently deliver memorable looks. This year, Steinfeld tapped into her own filmography, while in previous years, they’ve drawn inspiration from comedy classics and even hosted a circus-themed bash for the Bills team.
This post will walk through the couple’s best Halloween moments, from their most recent looks to their now-famous tributes to Adam Sandler’s cinematic universe.
This Year’s Look: A “Sinners” Throwback
For Halloween this year, Hailee Steinfeld paid homage to her own work, dressing up as her vampire character, Mary, from the movie Sinners. She revealed two distinct versions of the costume.
One look, shared in her Beau Society newsletter, featured a ’90s-inspired take on the character with high-waisted jeans, a leather jacket, and a high ponytail. The other interpretation showcased a more classic vampire aesthetic with slicked-back hair, bold makeup, and sharp fangs. Steinfeld has previously mentioned how much she enjoys seeing fans dress up as the character, and this year she joined in on the fun herself.
While Steinfeld fully embraced the theme, it wasn’t revealed if Allen dressed up as Stack, Mary’s love interest from the horror film.
A Tribute to “The Waterboy”
One of the couple’s most beloved costume sets was their tribute to the 1998 Adam Sandler comedy, The Waterboy. In a never-before-seen photo shared by Steinfeld, Josh Allen was dressed as the film’s main character, South Central Louisiana State University linebacker Bobby Boucher, complete with the iconic orange and blue jersey.
Steinfeld perfectly complemented his look by dressing as Bobby’s girlfriend, Vicki Vallencourt. The costumes were a hit with fans, who appreciated the throwback to the popular ’90s film and the couple’s “easy-going, fun energy.” The look has become so popular that fans now affectionately refer to Steinfeld as “Mrs. Vallencourt” when she appears at games to support Allen.
The Circus-Themed Party
Last year, Allen and Steinfeld took their Halloween celebrations to the next level by hosting the annual Bills team party. The couple chose a circus theme and dressed up as a ringmaster duo. This event also gave fans a rare public display of affection from the otherwise private couple.
The party took place on the same night as a game between the Kansas City Chiefs and the Washington Commanders. Instead of watching their upcoming opponents, the Bills team, led by their quarterback and his partner, embraced the Halloween spirit.
What’s Next for the Couple?
Josh Allen has spoken warmly about his relationship with Steinfeld, calling her an “unbelievable and undeniable rockstar” and “everything I need in my life.” Steinfeld, in turn, has talked about how she organizes her schedule to support Allen during his demanding football season and how she has learned to slow down and appreciate sharing her life with someone.
Their annual Halloween tradition offers a fun and creative outlet that fans have come to love. As another Halloween passes, fans are already looking forward to seeing what iconic duo Josh Allen and Hailee Steinfeld will bring to life next year.
Looking to recreate Hailee Steinfeld’s bold vampire look from Sinners? Achieve that flawless, dramatic makeup with the NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer for a smooth base and the NYX Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner for those sharp, defined lines. Don’t forget to add a touch of mystery with the Rare Beauty Positive Light Liquid Luminizer for a radiant glow. Shop these essentials now: NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer, NYX Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner, and Rare Beauty Positive Light Liquid Luminizer.